Valero Energy’s (VLO) record results improved its business outlook, but the stock’s rise has already outpaced the upgrade in the company’s valuation, says Freedom Broker senior analyst Sergey Pigarev. He raised the target price from $276 to $358 while downgrading the rating from “Hold” to “Sell.”
Versus the price of $426.28 used in the report dated October 26, the new target implies a decline of about 16%. In the analyst’s view, the market is pricing in peak refining profitability as if it will persist for several years.
Valero is one of the largest independent oil refiners in the United States. The company produces gasoline, diesel fuel and other petroleum products, and is also expanding production of renewable diesel and ethanol.

Fuel shortage delivered record profit
According to its Q3 2026 report, Valero’s adjusted net income reached $6.8 bn, or $23.90 per share. A year earlier, earnings per share were $3.66.
Freedom’s analysis shows that compared with Q2, adjusted EPS nearly doubled, from $12.54. Revenue rose 43.3% year over year to $46.1 bn, while adjusted EBITDA totaled $9.8 bn.
The main support came from a shortage of petroleum products, primarily diesel fuel. The spread between diesel prices and crude oil costs on the U.S. Gulf Coast increased 66.1% over the quarter to $72.27 per barrel. This indicator reflects market refining conditions, but it is not equal to a plant’s net profit: production and other costs still have to be covered from it.
Cash exceeded debt
Valero’s operating cash flow was $6.9 bn with capital expenditures of $432 mn. The company ended the quarter with $9.8 bn in cash and about $8.6 bn in debt.
By Freedom’s calculations, the net cash position reached about $1.3 bn excluding finance lease obligations. This means that on this basis cash exceeded debt.
Valero returned about $3.8 bn to shareholders through dividends and buybacks. The analyst estimates that roughly $3.4 bn was spent on repurchasing its own shares.
Other segments showed mixed dynamics
Operating profit in the renewable diesel segment amounted to $353 mn. The segment remained profitable, but the result was roughly halved compared with Q2.
It was affected by a high comparison base, the shutdown of one facility due to a storm, and fluctuations in the cost of regulatory certificates linked to the use of renewable fuel.
Ethanol production reached a record, but operating profit in this segment also declined versus the previous quarter, to $272 mn. Thus, traditional refining made the main contribution to the group’s record result.
Why high profit was not a reason to buy
Freedom significantly raised its forecasts for Valero for 2026–2027 and factored in higher earnings for the period through 2028. However, since the August review the shares have risen by about 36% and at the time of the analysis were trading 19% above the new target price.
Pigarev expects margins to decline in Q4, although they may remain well above average cycle levels. If the fuel shortage begins to ease, the current record profitability may prove temporary.
Previously, Freedom Broker reported on a project to supply fuel from Texas to the U.S. West. The publication noted that new infrastructure could partially offset the reduction in refining capacity in California, including Valero’s refinery in Benicia.
Under Freedom’s current assessment, Valero’s strong financial position does not eliminate the risk of the stock being overvalued: its price depends not only on today’s records, but also on the sustainability of future earnings.
Not an individual investment recommendation.